Tuesday, May 10, 2011

Behaviorism in Practice

In the infed article, The Behaviorist Orientation to Learning, author, Mark K. Smith, reports that researcher, James Hartley, has developed four principles that build upon operate conditioning as identified by behaviorist, Skinner, and the research environment, as proposed by behaviorist, Watson. In his report Hartley includes the following as one of the four principles:
• Repetition, generalization, and discrimination are important notions. Frequent practice-and practice with varied contexts-is necessary for learning to take place. Skills are not acquired without frequent practice.
The idea of “focused practice” is particularly important when students are practicing a complex multistep step skill or process, such as research process, scientific inquiry, or the writing practice (Marzano, Pickering, Pollock 2001 pg.70 ). According to the authors, Pitler, Hubbell, Kuhn, and Malenoski, in their book, Using Technology with Classroom Instruction that Works, Multiple exposures to material help students deepen their understanding of content and become proficient with skill. Typically, students need about 24 hours practice sessions with a skill in order to achieve 80-percent competency (Hubble, Kuhn, Malenoski, Pitler, 2007 pg.188 ). They also add that technology facilitates homework and practice by providing a wealth of resources for learning outside of the classroom, making it easy for students to work on collaborative homework assignments and providing drill and practice resources that help students refine their skills.
Hartley’s next principle is on the subject of reinforcement:
• Reinforcement is the cardinal motivation. Positive reinforces like rewards and successes are preferable to negative events like punishment and failures. In the previous mention book, Using Technology with Classroom Instruction that Works, the authors write, The instructional strategy of reinforcing effort enhances students’ understanding of the relationship between effort and achievement by addressing their beliefs about learning (Hubble, Kuhn, Malenoski, Pitler, 2007.pg.155)
In my twenty plus years of facilitating student use of computer software for educational games, I have never experienced a game that reprimanded a student for an incorrect answer. Even when the student misses an answer the “negative” response is done in a positive fashion. Often, and especially in games for young children, a correct response with educational games will often have a reward such as music or a cartoon figure do a jig or dance. Positive feedback is a powerful reinforcement. Feedback should be timely. In general, the more delay that occurs in giving feedback, the less improvement there is in achievement (Marzano, Pickering, Pollock, 2001. pg.97 ). Another positive reinforcer I connect with technology is the programs that teach each student at his or her learning level. By working at the level the student is ready to learn at makes the student feel more successful and that in turn boosts confidence as well as the desire to keep trying.

References:

Hubble, E.R., Kuhn, M., Malenoski, K., Pitler, H. (2007). Using technology with
classroom instruction that works. ASCD. Alexandria, VA.

Marzano, R.J., Pickering, D.J., Pollock, J.E.(2001). Classroom instruction that
works.-research strategies for increasing student achievement. ASCD. Alexandria,
VA.
Smith, M.K. (1999) ‘The behaviourist orientation of learning’, the encyclopedia of
informal education. Retrieved from www.infed.org/biblio/learning- behavourist.htm

5 comments:

  1. Nancy,

    I enjoyed reading your post! You make great points using lots of information from our resources!

    Positive reinforcement is without a doubt more effective than negative reinforcement, but as a sub, I see more negatives. Many classrooms have discipline actions, such as writing the student's name on the board, which means losing recess time. If the undesirable behavior continues the student receives a check for each offense. Eventually, consequences can be to call home or be sent to the principal. While subbing in one particular class, I noticed that this "plan" did not even affect the students. It usually ends up being the same students writing their names on the board and they become desensitized to it. I subbed in this class for two days so I tried a different approach. I used the name on the board tactic but I also included a happy face where I added the names of students on task. It seemed to be quite effective.

    I have seen in some classrooms where the teacher uses a "clip chart" where students can move up with good behavior or down with bad. I find this to be a well balanced approach because it is also a positive reinforcement.

    What are your opinions or beliefs about Behaviorism? Do you believe it still has a relevant position in today's classrooms?

    ReplyDelete
  2. Heather and Nancy,
    I enjoyed reading both of your posts! I also prefer positive motivation as opposed to negative. I often point out the student on task in the classroom rather than the one that is not.

    A method of positive reinforcement that my daughter's 5th grade teacher used was called the Gold Coin party. The teacher had a jar on her desk. When the students were particularly well behave for a lesson or activity then the teacher would reward the class by adding a gold coin to the jar. Once the jar was full the class would be rewarded with a party during the last hour of school on Friday afternoon. The students really enjoyed the parties and it was a good incentive for staying on task.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Nancy,
    I love your comment about positive feedback being a positive reinforcement. I agree with you 100%. It is important to encourage students on what they did right on tests etc and not to just show what they missed. When a student feels good about accomplishments they are making, they will want to continue learning.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Nancy,
    In my opinion, the four principles of behaviorism, repetition, generalization, discrimination, and reinforcement are basically things that should be happening in the classroom anyway. These things help to make the classroom a safe place for students-a place where they know they can feel comfortable being wrong and unique. These also result in the classroom continuing to run smoothly in a teacher's absence.

    Good Point made about the computer games and the absence of reprimand!

    ReplyDelete
  5. Nancy I am mor favorable with the principles of repetition and reinforcement. We must help our students understand that if they do not practice skills and strategies, they may forget what the amin objective is. I believe in reinforcement whether positive or not. We must praise students for their accomplishments and redirect negative behavior.

    ReplyDelete